Add a spicy surprise to your order. What'll it be? A delicious mystery that will be revealed when you receive your package!  FAQs What are the spices worth? All surprise spices are full-sized jars that would typically cost $8.99–$11.99. How do you choose the spice? We'll randomly pick a surprise spice to add to your order. We try to avoid duplicates in your order, or from previous surprise spice orders, but it's always possible that you'll receive a spice you already have. Think of it as a great way to share your favorite new spice with a friend! Can I return the spice if I don't like it? Sorry, but no returns or exchanges for your mystery spice. That's the deal.